Key Takeaways
- U.S. equities extended their pullback, with the S&P 500 down about 8% from its October high and the VIX closing at 28.44, its highest since March 30.
- Raoul Pal argued that markets are mispricing compute as a cyclical commodity and that liquidity, not AI demand, is the real driver of the selloff.
- Ben Carlson and Meb Faber highlighted steep drawdowns across technology names, while Faber questioned the fees and shelf-space payments embedded in fund distribution.
- Reid Hoffman framed AI as a speed advantage for founders, while a widely shared adoption forecast projected a sharp rise in daily AI use among knowledge workers.
- Regional manufacturing surveys showed mixed signals: Kansas City's index rose to 18, but Philadelphia's new orders and backlog turned negative for the first time since May.
1. Equity Pullback and Volatility
- The S&P 500 fell 2% on the day to its lowest close since April and stood 8% below its October 6 high, the third pullback of the year and the largest since March, according to Charlie Bilello. He noted this was the 34th drop of more than 5% from a high since the March 2009 low and characterized the moves as the normal cost of equity investing. The VIX closed at 28.44, its highest since March 30, and Bilello said rising fear offers long-term investors cheaper stocks. — via 1 2 3 4 5
- Bilello also listed drawdowns from historical highs across assets, including Nvidia at -40%, Bitcoin at -51%, Ethereum at -65% and gold at -35%, and noted that silver and gold had reversed from strong year-to-date gains in January to year-to-date losses. Ben Carlson separately reported an 8.2% S&P 500 drawdown, a 15.2% Nasdaq 100 drawdown and a 39% Nvidia drawdown. — via 1 2 3 4 5
- Carlson and Meb Faber both circulated lists of steep technology declines, including Micron at -49%, Seagate at -57%, Applied Materials at -57%, Oracle at -58%, Marvell at -60%, Intel at -61% and SanDisk at -72%. Faber argued that the common claim “I can't sell that stock, the taxes will kill me” often leads to major losses. — via 1 2
2. AI, Liquidity and Market Pricing
- Raoul Pal said compute is the one commodity with near-unlimited demand, yet the market prices it as a cyclical commodity about to peak and roll over. He and Andreas Steno discussed why they believe the market is misjudging the AI trade, what is really driving the selloff and what it means for crypto assets. Pal said the underlying issue remains liquidity and that he will argue in Abu Dhabi that the entire system is being repriced beneath investors' feet. — via 1 2
- Pal said he has used a single global liquidity chart for a decade to explain nearly all major asset moves, a thesis developed in his book “The Everything Code,” scheduled for publication on November 3. The framework combines demographics, debt and liquidity: a shrinking working-age population, debt-financed growth and debt repaid through currency debasement imply a hurdle return of roughly 8% a year, which he said most finance professionals fail to meet. — via 1
- Pal said the “Exponential Age” he described in 2020-2021 sounded like a slogan at the time, but five years later AI and digital assets are compounding simultaneously, and he believes the world has entered an acceleration phase of that era. — via 1
3. Founder Playbooks and AI Adoption
- Reid Hoffman argued that AI's real superpower for founders is speed, not just intelligence, comparing startup competition to the OODA loop of observe, orient, decide and act. He said speed helps founders spot market opportunities earlier, ship the right product sooner and scale first, and described active entrepreneurs who let AI agents work through the afternoon or evening and check results first thing the next morning, while saying he does not advocate all-night work. — via 1
- Hoffman said he led OpenAI's first commercial financing round when the company had no go-to-market plan, business plan or product, betting on a “dream team” including Ilya and Dario and on what he called magical technology. He said the round came about because Sam Altman told him pure charitable funding could not sustain the effort and asked him to lead a commercial fund, which Hoffman agreed to do and helped raise. — via 1
- A widely shared adoption forecast claimed that only 1% of knowledge workers actively use AI today and projected that within two years 90% will use it more than six hours a day at three times today's token consumption per hour, lifting revenue per employee from $500,000-$1 million to $3 million-$10 million. The same thread cited a team whose active AI use rose from under 5% 18 months ago to over 90% this week after bot deployments, and argued that institutions constrained by 12-24 month IRR and ROIC cycles are structurally disadvantaged versus long-term individual investors. — via 1 2 3
4. Fund Fees, Distribution and Manufacturing Data
- Meb Faber questioned why U.S. pensions and endowments, with more than $10 trillion in combined assets, pay all-in fees of about 2.5% for large endowments and 1.3% for public pensions, versus about 0.25% for endowment-style ETFs, leaving typical institutions paying 5-10 times more. He also said Fidelity and Charles Schwab, which control much of retail and RIA distribution, demand roughly 15% of ETF revenue as shelf-space fees, and that investors pay up to $100 more per purchase if a fund refuses; antitrust lawyers he consulted see a viable lawsuit, but he asked why none has been filed. — via 1 2
- Faber highlighted Cambria's FYLD ETF, which focuses on international companies with high cash distributions through dividends, buybacks and debt repayment, grouped as shareholder yield. He also relayed that AAUD launched through the 351 Exchange, with AAUE scheduled for March 18 using a similar strategy for U.S. large-cap blend exposure plus dividend management at a 9 basis point fee. — via 1 2
- Liz Ann Sonders reported that the October Kansas City Fed manufacturing index came in at 18 versus an expected 11 and a prior 11, with new orders at 16, shipments at 23, prices paid at 53 and employment at 15. After ISM-method adjustments, both the November Philadelphia and Kansas City Fed manufacturing indexes rose and stayed in expansion, but prices paid diverged: Philadelphia jumped while Kansas City fell 17 points. Philadelphia's new orders and backlog turned negative for the first time since May, while Kansas City's employment component surged to its highest since June 2022. — via 1 2 3 4 5
5. IPO Timing and Valuation Debate
- Charlie Bilello said 2026 U.S. IPO issuance rose to $261 billion, second only to 2021, and noted that the prior two IPO booms, in 1999-2000 and 2020-2021, were followed by tougher markets. His conclusion was that Wall Street's best time to sell IPOs to the public is often the public's worst time to buy them. — via 1 2
- Aswath Damodaran said the fallout around Jensen Huang has persisted for three weeks, hitting the company's board and employees, and that the market response has cut nearly $1.5 trillion from the company's market value. — via 1
- Elad Gil congratulated the Anthropic team on completing an IPO and said the company is expanding its influence and moving toward “singularity.” Meb Faber separately congratulated Anthropic and SpaceX on creating 10,000 new millionaires, saying American capitalism is at its best and that these companies would not exist without their employees; the cited post said Anthropic's 5,300 founders and employees are now worth more than the bottom third of U.S. households, or 45 million families. — via 1 2
